Doctor’s Waiting Room, Manhattan, Upper East Side, March 21,
2002. I sit, embroidery in hand, stitching away the interminable,
manically neurotic monologue of the mother beside me – a woman so
frightened of her daughter’s simple, routine, virtually no-risk
procedure that it requires the careful, exhaustive coaxing of the very
busy, very kind gastro-enterologist before she will agree to it. Laboring
under the nagging premonition that my husband’s colonoscopy will
prove to be anything but routine, I am nonetheless calm, in my safe place
where, as long as my hands are busy, I can find peace. Does anyone know
that these stitches, these thoughts, hold the last innocence, the last
moments of the space in time when I do not yet know my husband will die?
It is our son’s 12th birthday. A school day. The
bowling party is in three days. “Gotta remember the Krispy Kremes,”
I think.
The crazy lady is still mid-monologue, and I hear my name.
It’s the same busy, kind GNT. He calls me Mrs. Moore, and asks me
to sit down. It’s post-procedure, he says – my husband is
recovering, but has given permission to tell me – what? If anybody
has the tape, I’d be fascinated to know all of what he said. All
I really remember is, “It looks like cancer.” Just like that.
Not, “We need to run more tests.” Or, “It’s probably
nothing, but we’d like to do a biopsy.” Or, “I don’t
want to frighten you – it could be a lot of things.” Just
… cancer. So clear there was no other possibility. No detour. No
escape route. No chance. No hope. I go numb, and try to listen –
we need surgery, we need a CAT scan, we need to know if it’s spread,
we need a plan. When what we really need is re-wind – lots and lots
of re-wind.
Other things I remember: A mutual pledge to “fight
this.” Taking notes. Being home. Him stoic. Me frozen. His going
to work. My rising hysteria.
But wait. I know people with cancer. People who’ve
survived, who are leading full lives, who are in remission, who are cured.
And my husband is young. And strong. And fit. And funny. And brilliant.
Take a deep breath, tough girl. This will be hard, but you’re smart.
You’re brave. You’re relentless. You’ll figure this
out – it’s what you do.
But how? How do you start when you feel like someone just
slipped you a Mickey, when you can’t understand English, when you
don’t remember what was just said – even though you wrote
it down?
Oh. Right. Friends. Help. Please. Now.
Understand here that our marriage had always thrived on
a clear division of labor, not necessarily a traditional division, but
a division nonetheless. He was the intellectual one who lived for ideas,
for books, for running, for work – the modest, stunningly witty
one, content to cede me the spotlight. I was the smart, practical one
– the chatty, chronically social one who knew where everything was,
who trouble shot logistics, who ran the show.
I started running. With a phone call to a doctor friend,
who took the call, who didn’t put me on hold, who promised to find
out what I needed to know. And did. And my chest began to de-constrict
– a little. Then – seemingly within hours – it all got
way, way more complicated. The phone just wasn’t working for me.
There were too many people to call. And too much information to convey.
And too much emotion to contain. I was burning out before I’d gone
24 hours. When I remembered.
E-mail. But was it appropriate? Was it fair? Was it right?
Whether it was any of those things, I was desperate. I was drowning in
questions, in information, in tears. But it was my job to run the show
– and we were all counting on that. So while, with enormous
courage, determination and good humor, the patient kept going,
I knew it was up to me to mastermind the research, the bureaucracy, the
communication. But again, email – in the face of tragedy?
Frankly, I saw no other way out. So I took a huge leap of faith, and decided
that, if I was careful and honest, I could get away with it. Within 48
hours of Diagnosis Day, I sent what became the first Update – which
to me reads now as a bit earnest, a bit tentative, perhaps a bit teary.
Quickly, a breezier, more irreverent style evolved – a direct reflection
of our need to share whatever hope and optimism we could muster. Besides,
our family style is funny – we are diehard fans of wit and addicted
to laughter.
I know, I know – life is real, life is earnest –
and cancer is more real, and more earnest. But, let
cancer become life and, like a Potteresque Death Eater, it’ll
suck the joy right out. So we laughed our way through – and I documented
– a vacation house roof cave-in, a night in pediatric emergency
(where my son re-cast all the doctors as ER actors), an April
Fool’s Day surgery date, an unwelcome though well-intentioned visit
to my husband’s atheistic bedside from Sister Eileen, an interminable
drug lottery, a hospital roommate with no discernible psychological boundaries,
my inept attempts at needle therapy – I could go on, but surely
you get the drift. Given the choice between collective wrist slitting,
voluntary commitment procedures or laughter, we chose laughter. And whether
or not we shocked – even offended – some people, we only caved
when we were forced to, and we (mostly) prevented ourselves from squandering
the time we had.
The Update List grew like Topsy, and traveled the world.
It started with dozens, and grew exponentially, as friends sent my missives
to their own lists (even, with my enthusiastic permission, to people I
didn’t know), as acquaintances found out and asked to be kept up-to-date,
as kind medical professionals became interested in us and asked to follow
our progress. Some people even began to hunger for plot – when my
mother, having been away, sent only the latest Update to her own list,
someone objected, “It’s not just the news – it’s
the story.” Which is part of the reason the Updates kept
me sane. People wanted to read them – they cared about
us, they wanted to know, and they needed to believe that we still smiled.
Funnily enough, my husband was the only one who seemed to have no interest
in actually reading (much less writing) them, but he knew how important
they were to me – and to the rest of our world – and I think
he felt ultimately nurtured by them, certainly by the response they generated.
I began to feel, in an odd but ultimately therapeutic
way, an obligation to keep in touch. I knew no one would criticize me
if I didn’t, but I had started this thing, and it was serving me
beautifully. I was keeping everybody up to date, and in the loop, efficiently,
without endless repetitive conversations which I knew would wreck me emotionally.
I used the Updates to make requests for information, and to ask for specific
help. When I needed something (virtually anything) I was able to craft
a request and simultaneously ask dozens of people at once. And, perhaps
most important, my Updates genuinely made me feel better. I would
think, “Time to write one,” often believing I had nothing
remotely hopeful or humorous to offer. But a keyboard hour later, I’d
have come up with something (there’s always material, if you really
look – and it’s all about perspective, always), and I’d
push back from the computer, rejuvenated for another round of cancer care.
Obviously, there were times I gave in to self-pity, and
fear, and anger. When I really needed to vent, I did (I just tried to
do it selectively, and rarely, which helped me keep my equilibrium –
and my audience). In fact, as the ordeal wore on, I often wrote when I
felt most in need of comfort; I knew my emails would trigger response,
and always felt a renewed sense of support and love after I sent them.
Of course, I also communicated privately with my closest intimates, but
in writing my main Updates for a common denominator, I kept a perspective
that might otherwise have been unavailable to me. And when the end came
(make no mistake; I knew it was coming), I was even able to pre-write
a large piece of the email containing the news. So that, in a way, I was
able to continue a personal dialogue with each recipient, something that
would have been impossible otherwise. And in the days and weeks that followed
those final hours, my consistently bulging electronic inbox kept me grounded,
kept me occupied, kept me connected.
I know there’s a lot of whining about email –
it’s impersonal, it’s dangerous, it’s sloppy, it lives
forever on your ex’s hard drive. I’ve heard it all, and I
get it. But I’m not giving it up. Without it, I doubt my sanity
would have survived. And I still thrive on its predictable, consistent
solace. However, though I promised, in the aftermath, to keep in touch
with everybody on the Update List – and will – I really thought
the exchanges would grow less frantic, less perpetual, less important.
And those particular exchanges did.
But apparently, email itself was not through with me.
Fast forward to two months after the memorial. My son
and I are re-grouping, finding a new rhythm not dictated by treatment
schedules, raised and dashed hopes, brutal medical choices, increasing
frailty, inescapable wasting, hospice. We’re actually (and I say
this with extreme caution) fine. We’re sad, and we’re
probably a little fragile ourselves, but we’re life lovers (we learned
from the best) and if the truth be really told, we’re even relieved
– there’s no more pain, and reclaiming normal is starting
to feel pretty good. Prolonged caretaking breeds hunger – for life,
for health, for fun. And we’ve always been very big on fun.
In pursuit of that, I found myself one night at a dinner
party with seven other women, ranging in age from 35 to 85—all of
them single, and all of them whining (there’s really an astounding
amount of that in the world) about meeting men – or more specifically,
not meeting men. “Men,” I thought, thinking wistfully back
to that glorious moment years ago when my then-boyfriend and I had celebrated
the fact that we’d never have to date again. “Welcome
back to the world.”
Posh Mid-Town Manhattan Apartment, Fall, 2004. The
conversation:
A very stylish 50-something interior designer: “I
haven’t seen a likely contender since my divorce. Romance sounds
great, but clearly my grandchildren will be giving me the hugs from now
on.”
A 40ish lawyer: “If those ‘Sex and the City’
girls and their Manolos were man-challenged, there is simply
no hope.”
The 85-year old (interestingly, the most optimistic):
“I’d try again. But where would I even start?”
Me (I may have been mired in tragedy, but I read
– and I spend my life in front of a computer): “Online
dating?”
EVERYONE ELSE: “No way. For losers only. Those guys
are all 25. Too scary.” And the big finish, “What would we
say?”
I was hearing, but I just wasn’t believing. I mean,
admittedly online had literally saved my life, and maybe it’s not
the answer for everything, but I couldn’t let this go. “Oh,
come on – how hard could it be?” Silence. “I’ll
help you.” Suspicious looks. “Anyone?” Change of subject.
So. I had no takers, but was already hooked on the whole
idea. I may have been widowed for only a few months, but those years of
total immersion in caretaking, following a very early terminal diagnosis,
had created in me a sense of equally early acceptance along with the grief,
and frankly, a hunger for romance. I loved the idea of playing online
matchmaker, of setting my friends up with prose so scintillating, so evocative,
so appealing, that I’d spend the next five years attending fabulous
weddings at which I’d be the heroine of the hour (I’ve always
had a rich fantasy life, and a penchant for the spotlight). And full disclosure:
I realized I needed the hope myself – the hope that someday, somewhere
there might be someone else for me. I remembered a friend’s
story about demanding a psychic predict a new man and happiness
weeks after she’d been widowed. “I get it,” I thought,
“I get it.”
So, whether or not anyone was with me, and feeling somehow
like a naughty child, I sat down in front of my computer, signed on, and
began to peruse. And was appalled. Not at my friends’ perceived
paucity of eligible potential partners – a lot of the people hinted
at hidden fabulousness, despite their profiles (those 300 word
“Who I Am and Who I Want to Date” essays which are supposed
to make hearts beat faster at the prospect of connection). Most of them
were, in a word, awful. Anemic, boring, cliché-ridden, generally
inept in every conceivable way. I’m a writer, and a marketer, and
my spin-meister impulses went into overdrive almost of their own volition.
I had to try this.
But, despite oft-heard tales of match.com marriages and jdate successes,
my single friends, one by one, all wimped out. Who was left? Oh. Right.
Me. Feeling really scandalous by this time (how long before a
widow doesn’t feel unfaithful? was I ready? who would judge me?
what would my mother say?) I wrote a profile in my characteristically
irreverent voice, located a good, clear photo on my computer, got out
my credit card, and clicked “Publish.” And within days (actually
hours), was flooded with emails and date offers from men who seemed viable
at least, perhaps terrific. I had to get past a lot of hazy photos, a
lot of “walks on the beach,” and a lot of truly terrible grammar,
but the potential gems began to emerge. There was a doctor who sounded
funnier than Conan. A teacher who looked sexier than Liam. A writer who
could cook and dance. Heady stuff. I felt my own wounded, dormant
heart start to beat in anticipation – I’ve always had a resilient
streak, and I started to think, “Maybe I’m not done yet.”
But Oh God, dating? Email was one thing, but
telephone calls from strange men after 16 years with a one-and-only? And
actually meeting one, live and in person? Did I have anything
interesting to say? Did I remember how to flirt? Would anybody seem attractive?
If someone did, was I even capable of responding? Was I hopelessly out
of touch? Had mores changed? Had men morphed into unrecognizability?
Then I realized – what was my choice? I could make
peace with being alone (not an option), or I could get out there and test
the proverbial waters. And yes, of course there are other ways to go (the
fixup, the chance meeting, the classes, the benefits), but this was the
way that had presented itself first. So (naturally) I dove in.
The stories are already metaphoric, iconic, funny, sad, hopeful, sweet,
endless. There was the neo-natal surgeon (how can you not love a man who
takes care of critically ill babies?) whose only conversational
passion was geology. The big-time investment banker who made it clear
that Friends With Benefits was the only way to fly. The artist who wanted
to talk all night every night … period. The analyst who earnestly
speculated that I must be looking for a carbon copy of my late
husband, because he knew that otherwise I would definitely see him again.
The environmentalist who was just … how can I delicately put this?
… boring (actually, there was a lot of this – boring, not
earth saving). There was also a lot of self-absorbed, a lot of humorless,
a lot of entitled. And a lot of well-intentioned, a lot of bright,
a lot of generous, which unfortunately – for me anyway – came
without a lot of sparks.
Then there was The Smile Guy (a friend’s moniker
to distinguish him from the masses – and it is a killer
smile). Who was literate and friendly on email (check), easy and fun on
the phone (double check), and delicious in person (the dating
trifecta). Could this be my old pal Chemistry (I was starting to think
he’d taken up permanent residence with my high school boyfriend
in Minnesota – where I would not be caught dead)? Indeed –
it became quickly apparent that this man had happy energy, real curiosity,
a kind heart, passion for me like I only dimly remembered, and by the
way, Analyst Guy, zero resemblance to my late husband. It was easy, unambivalent,
and altogether dazzling. It was bliss. And almost as quickly as it began,
it was over. Neither one of us could really tell you why, and it doesn’t
really matter. Not for this story, anyway.